Today, Muslims in Asia (Afghanistan) joined the protest, whicspread like wildfire throughout the Middle East last week after European newspapers published caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad – drawn by Danish cartoonists. Unfortunately, most Europeans seem as dumfounded by their grievance as the French were about the grievances that ignited a fiery rampage amongst Muslim youths 3 months ago.
Of course, I can understand how centuries of cultural arrogance made the French ignorant of (indeed inured to) simmering rage amongst disenfranchised, disillusioned and disaffected Muslim youths. I can even understand how a gaggle of 12 cartoonists thought they had creative license to perpetrate this religious insult. However, I find it utterly deplorable that European editors published these caricatures knowing full-well that Muslims would consider them a desecration of their religion.
This was a callous, pernicious and blasphemous provocation – made craven by the specious justification that it was done in the spirit of freedom of the press. And, it only added fuel to Muslims’ understandable fury when German Chancellor Angela Merkel gave this lame justification state sanction by declaring that “freedom of the press is one of the great assets as a component of democracy….”
Besides, these 12 Tom Paine (“give me liberty or give me death”) wanna-bee disciples are hardly worthy of such principled ambition. Because, instead of standing up for this freedom, they’ve actually gone into hiding, fearing for their lives. Moreover, it betrays a hegemonic religious mindset that – instead of condemning this provocation – so many Europeans seem indignant about the Muslims’ reaction to it.
Indeed, this episode only feeds the suspicion amongst radical Muslims that their religion is under siege all over the world. And Iran’s President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad did not miss this opportunity to stoke these fires by declaring that:
“the caricatures showed the impudence and rudeness of Western newspapers against the prophet as well as the “maximum resentment of the Zionists (Jews) ruling these countries against Islam and Muslims.”
Many Christians glory in the caricatures of Jesus Christ. But for them to expect Muslims to idolize caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad in similar fashion is every bit as presumptuous as President Bush expecting that if given the chance to participate in free and fair elections, Muslims would only choose a government that pledges overt allegiance to the United States. After all, it is generally recognized that Islamic law forbids any depictions of the Prophet Muhammad for fear they could lead to idolatry.
To his credit, Pope Benedict XVI has offered the only appropriate reaction to this conflagration. He deplored the violence but added that:
“Certain provocative forms of criticism were unacceptable….The right to freedom of thought and expression…cannot entail the right to offend the religious sentiment of believers.”
Amen!
So, in this latest clash of civilizations, Muslims are burning businesses and embassies instead of cars. But it behooves us to appreciate that it could be more than just fire next time….
Note: I don’t mean to challenge them, but am I the only one who wonders why there have been no significant protests over these cartoons amongst America’s significant Muslim population?
Caricatures of Prophet Muhammad, Muslims fiery reaction, Danish cartoonists
Jennifer says
Hi Anthony
I was beginning to wonder if you were going to write on this. As always you put things into great perspective. I did not think to compare this to the french riots. It’s so true though.
Anonymous says
those arrogant sobs in europe should pay for this. they knew what they were doing. and they wonder why muslims want to burn down their cities. i like your comparison to bush because these same people like to accuse him of arrogance. they are hypocrites!!!!
Dave says
I think the most interesting thing I’ve read about this controversy, and I’ve read a lot, is your point about the assumption that because Christians idolize pictures of Christ then what’s the big deal if a few pictures of Mohammed are published. This is as you say all about religious hegemony.
Anonymous says
If people would stop being emotional in our world and be more logical then we would live in a better society and we wouldn’t have the problems that we have in our world. The fact remains that religion is used to control people. Take out religion and you lose the control.
Anonymous says
Hey anonymous
You “take out religion and you lose the control” is right. But then you get anarchy and mayhem. Instead of taking out religion we just need to respect and tolerate other people’s religion.
Pete
Howlleo says
Maybe it is simply immature and antisocial to react with murder and mayhem to provocation… Civilized countries use the UN and other forums to air their disagreements. Riot is unacceptable.
WE SHOULD NOT say things like “it could be more than fire next time” because that is what they want. They want us TERRIFIED of them- so they can do what they want.
DONT GIVE IN.